Tuesday, May 15, 2012

My story about going to jail

Brazil in Cayman
This has been a very strange thing for me.  It has taken me awhile to process.
A word about the photo:
This photo was taken at the Immigration office in Grand Cayman.  Note the pictures of the King and Queen of England.  Also note all the glass booths.  There is a computer terminal which you sign in with that places you into one of about a dozen possible queues.  You take a seat and a monitor overhead shows how long your wait time is.  Mine was 45 minutes to get an extension to my visit.  All the other queues happened to be about 2 minutes strangely enough.
The place gave me the creeps.  People behind the glass moved slower than Cayman Turtles and could care less how efficient things were done.  The people all sat in the nice air conditioned room waiting their turn - their liberty suspended - as they were "processed".
Cayman bureaucracy is worse than your DMV in the states.  It blows me away how bloated the government is there despite the fact that the country only has a population of about 60,000.
The Facts:
I was invited to come work for a company in the Cayman Islands as CTO for a start up company.  The idea was that I would work for a month and then consider if I wanted to make a longer commitment.
I arrived in Nassau, Bahamas to work on a off-shore project while the central office got me a temporary work permit.  But lines got crossed and my paperwork didn't get to the central Cayman office for a week.  It became impossible to get a work permit in time.  After two weeks I was flown to Grand Cayman to start work on what I came there for.
It was a little disconcerting to be working when it was illegal but I was assured there would be no problems.
About 2 weeks in the shop I was working at was raided by the immigration authorities.  They walked in like they owned the place and one officer came up behind me as I was composing some email and asked me "are you working here?" and I foolishly responded "yes" before even seeing who it was.  As soon as I saw that it was an immigration officer I added "but I haven't been paid".
Now it turns out that in Grand Cayman, "working" is a vague term apparently.  If it "appears" you are working, then you are working.  If you are seeking employment - then you are working.  If you are volunteering to help someone accomplish something - even for free - you are "working".
The Cayman Islands don't have income or property taxes.  They make their income from import and export duties and ... you guessed it: work permits.
Work permits in the Caymans can cost an employer thousands of dollars and much bureaucratic hassle.  Prospective employees must be off-shore while their work permits are being processed.  Work permits are for a limited time for a specific postion with a specific employer.
So far this seems pretty reasonable to me.  A country should have the right to protect its own people from loosing job opportunities to foreigners.  A simple work permit, if done reasonably and quickly seems like a pretty fair tax to me.
The Bust
When the authorities raided the business I was working for, they pulled aside 6 of us and took our IDs and passports.  Eventually we were cuffed and taken in a van to the Enforcement office of Immigration.  The silly thing here is that none of us showed the slightest resting of arrest - we were very cooperative - yet cuffing as "policy" we were told and was simply "required".  We were placed in cells, 3 guys to each cell, and awaited "processing".  I have pictures of me in cuffs but at this time I cannot access them.  I will try to add them when I get a hold of them.
The Process
Being "processed" means you are under "suspicion" of a crime and must be photographed, fingerprinted, and a "statement" taken.  "Book'em Danno!" 
The 6 of us were processed by at least 4 officers in only 9 hours!!!  That's right.  I would think it was a record for inefficiency.
I was the last one to be done and I offered to type up my own statement - as the officer was a pretty bad typist.  We had a meal while there as the bust was on a Friday afternoon and by now it was 9 PM.  I got out of there around midnight.
My boss came in to help get us out of jail.  I was advised not to request a lawyer to be present by my boss - mainly because at that time on a Friday, it's pretty much impossible to get a lawyer and there isn't much a lawyer can do for you either.
The "statement" you must provide is their way of gathering evidence against you - just like their question asked of me while my back was turned.  We were marandized AFTER the fact which I think should make my admission of "working" inadmissible.
Anyway, none of us could leave till we signed a bail agreement subjecting us to a hefty fine and/or significant jail time if we didn't show up the next week at the Immigration office for further "processing".
My boss got out of there around 2AM.
The Story
You see, the officers explained to us that they were assembling a very large "file" on us and when it was done, their supervisor would be consulted to determine if there was sufficient evidence to push for prosecution.
This sounds quite reasonable till you find out what happens next.
The Hook
The jail time was fun at first but after about 2 hours the fun was gone and it was just getting ridiculous.  We came back as instructed the next week for further processing.  We had to be there by 10 AM and could not leave till dismissed.  We waited 2 hours before anyone would see us.  After more time they said they just weren't ready to finish us up so we had to sign another bail agreement to come back again the next week.  Note that their bail forms have about 6 spaces for re-setting the appearance time to a later time.  Each time we had to come back, a different officer would be on the form so every time we had to go over everything again - as if nothing had been processed before.
One of us had just left another job in the Cayman Islands in order to start a new job at our business.  He had scheduled a flight off the island for a few weeks so his temporary work permit could be processed.  But they held him till AFTER his flight, forcing him to expend significant money to reschedule to a later time.  It was difficult for him to reschedule because there was no indication of when Immigration might be through with him.  So here is a guy that is in trouble because he was there, yet processing him for this violation causes him to be unable to leave.  Ironic no?
The room you wait in is interesting.  On the wall is this big picture that says people that even talk offensive will be jailed.  Then there are the articles on the wall telling about business men that were fined like $40,000 because their employee skipped bail.  Also interestingly enough is a summary of the immigration laws.  Did you know that if you happen to work for the government - the whole work permit hassle is waved?  That could be a handy thing to know someday.
The next week we came back and had a very similar experience.  We waited 2 hours before anyone would see us, screwed around with the officer, and were eventually re bailed.  I explained that I had a flight out the day before the next appointment and they had to see me sooner.  The officer said that I should come in at 8:30 the day of my flight and he would come in early and help me get finished in time to make my flight.  He gave me his home phone number and email so I could email him my itinerary.
I was there on time.  The office didn't even open till 9AM and I waited till 1PM before being able to talk to anyone.  The officer who promised to see me early "took the day off"!  Another officer spoke with my boss and we did everything we could to get them to hurry up - but I missed my flight.
It was interesting that an hour after my flight left, the officer came to an agreement with my boss to pay a fine and I was free to go.  I left the next day on a later flight costing about $1000.  My boss I believe had to pay about $4000 to get us out of that situation.
Coincidence?
Incidentally, shortly before my flight was to leave and as I was waiting in the office for processing, my friend said he had overheard the officers talking about "training" us.
Also, as I was being processed the first night in the cell, I noticed a white board in the office showing a table of years and fines and officer names - it was like a poll showing who got the biggest fines for each year.
The Legal Rub
What we have here, looking back on it, is a classic case of using the privilege of "detention" to extract evidence, confessions, and money from the "suspect" without the need of any hearing, trial, council, magistrate or jury.  Mind you, compared to other countries such as Mexico or Russia, I think we were handled pretty nicely.  I merely had to come home a day late and waste about 20 hours of my time and I was lucky to have a boss that cared and got me out of there quickly.
But the scary thing is - I could have been there indefinitely.  I remember my boss consulting with our lawyer about what to do, as they wanted him to basically sign a confession of guilt in order to pay the fine and get me out in time to catch my flight.  The lawyer said that it could take 6 months to a year to fight the charges and it would cost a fortune to do battle.  She advised that it definitely was worth admitting guilt and getting things over with.
So what we have here is a complete and effective bypass of due process using detention to wear down and pressure the suspects into forfeiting their rights.  The delays are just increased until the suspect (or should I say victim?) is begging to give them a confession and whatever fine is required - so they can go on with life.  The whole process is done in a nice civil fashion and unless you know your rights you would think things were just "normal due-process".  But actually, if you think about it, such "processing" is a minor "act of war" against your person and due-process is NOT what you are getting.
There is a reason the US Constitution guarantees a "speedy" trial and a trial by jury for cases involving more than $20 in value.
The fact is, because I and my boss were forced into confessing things we didn't want to confess or that weren't even true at all, the Cayman Immigration officials had all they needed to keep us for a very long time if they wanted to.  I could still be there to this day and much longer.  I could have even been beaten or starved or whatever they wanted to do to me - because without due process - there really is no law at all.
The Patriot Act authorizes indefinite detention for anyone suspected of "terrorism".  That means that ANY AMERICAN at ANY TIME and really for ANY REASON can be taken, locked up, tortured, whatever, with no due process.  That means, at least on paper, the law is no more.  There is no protection for any American from the government.  Public opinion has not yet been swayed enough to accept this in the open, but I am sure it's happening even now in secret.  Somewhere in America there is a poor suspect sitting in detention wondering if they will ever see freedom again.  There need be no real evidence.  There is no facing your accuser.  There is no peer review or common sense applied.  Your viewpoint, circumstances or even legal arguments have no bearing whatsoever.
It is interesting that Cayman Law is clearly based on Common Law but bureaucracy has twisted the whole thing into a mind numbing "process" that removes all lawful due-process from the affair.
This experience has really given me a lot to think about.  It's not so much what did happen - it's what could have happened.

Consider this and vote appropriately.


P.S. This just in from C4L...things are getting serious.  If you've never been detained for 9 hours, consider... forever!

Dear Sanford,

Today, Congress had a chance to fix a mess of their own making - and they blew it.

Instead of prohibiting indefinite detention of persons arrested on U.S. soil who have been merely accused of“substantially supporting” al Qaeda, the Taliban, or “associated forces,” Congress actually made things worse.

In a moment, I’ll ask that you contact Congress.

But first, allow me to briefly explain what happened.

As you should be aware, last year, Senator Carl Levin authored a provision, Section 1021 and 1022, into the FY 2012 National Defense Authorization Act that allows the President to indefinitely detain American citizens and foreigners who are arrested on U.S. soil on the mere accusation of supporting terrorism.

In a signing statement, the President assured Americans that he wouldn’t use this power.

With all due respect to the President, his word is not much to go on and certainly not enough to relieve my concerns.

That brings us to today.

Early this morning, Congress voted on the Smith(WA)/Amash/Berman/Garamendi/Duncan(TN)/Johnson(GA)/Gosar/Hirono/Paul/Jackson Lee/Tipton/Labrador Amendment that would have prevented indefinite detention of persons detained on U.S. soil.

This was the only amendment that would have substantively addressed the problem by definitively stating the President does not have the authority to indefinitely detain persons arrested on U.S. soil in military custody.

Unfortunately, it failed by a vote of
182-238.

There are several reasons for this.

For one, Congress was offered a smokescreen amendment that was voted on immediately after the Smith/Amash amendment was rejected.

This amendment, offered by Rep. Louie Gohmert (TX-1), was even worse than doing nothing, and it will likely exacerbate the problems and ambiguity regarding the detention of “suspected terrorists.”

The first part simply reiterates that Americans have Habeas Corpus rights.

Except no one is arguing otherwise.

In fact, the Constitution clearly states that the “Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended” unless by an act of Congress. Since Congress has not explicitly passed an act stating it is suspended, all persons in the United States have that right.

Where it has potential to make the problem worse is two-fold, as Steven Vladeck blogged at
Lawfare:

First, it introduces uncertainty regarding whether individuals arrested within the United States but out of immigration status are entitled to pursue habeas relief (never mind the countless immigration cases where such relief has historically been available—and the compelling constitutional arguments supporting that jurisprudence). Second, the 30-day provision would arguably allow the government to preclude a detainee’s access to court (or counsel) for 30 days, whereas under current law, the detainee may file the moment he is ‘in custody under or by color of the authority of the United States.’”

So, in addition to rejecting an amendment that quite clearly would protect due process and the rule of law, Congress actually managed to make the situation much worse by passing the Gohmert amendment by a vote of
243-173.

Another reason for the Smith/Amash amendment failing is the outrageous and hyperbolic accusations lobbed at it from Wall Street Journal op-ed pages and even by alleged “Tea Party” members of Congress.

One such attack came from Rep. Tom Rooney (FL-16). Rooney issued a press release Thursday claiming the Smith/Amash amendment “coddled foreign enemy combatants” and would provide incentive for attacks on U.S. soil.

Excuse me, but since when did suicide terrorists suddenly begin to contemplate whether they’ll end up in a military tribunal or Article III court before carrying out their dastardly deeds?

In reality, if a terrorist were able to carry out an attack on U.S. soil, the government should look inward – at the failure of the intelligence community and their own national security state in this post-9/11 world.

Nevertheless, these are the sorts of absurd, illogical statements that were used to convince your member of Congress to vote against the only amendment that would have prevented the government from indefinitely detaining you.

By failing to adopt the Smith/Amash amendment, the government still has the authority to indefinitely detain anyone the government accuses of “supporting terrorism.”

And remember, not too long ago, it was C4L members who were listed in a Missouri Fusion Center report, later referred to as the MIAC report, as domestic extremists to be watched.

And it wasn’t just C4L members on that list, but people displaying third party logos and bumper stickers and supporters of specific politicians.

In the past, everyone from gun owners, to pro-lifers, to tea partiers, were labeled “terrorists” by their political opponents.

This is why it’s of the utmost importance that the indefinite detention of persons by the military be prohibited.

Perhaps this President won’t use such authority, but what about the next? And the one after that?
R 112 2nd U.S. House of Representatives 270 H R 4310 On Agreeing to the Amendment 29 Smith of Washington Amendment No. 46 
RECORDED VOTE Failed 18-May-2012 9:45 AM 
Party       Ayes Noes Answered"Present” Not Voting
Republican  19   219  0                 3
Democratic  163  19   0                 8
Independent 0    0    0                 0
Totals      182  238  0                 11

Against Detention          For Detention            Not Active

Ackerman          Aye      Adams             No     Amodei            NotVoting 
Altmire           Aye      Aderholt          No     Cardoza           NotVoting 
Amash             Aye      Akin              No     Clay              NotVoting 
Andrews           Aye      Alexander         No     Costello          NotVoting 
Baca              Aye      Austria           No     Filner            NotVoting 
Baldwin           Aye      Bachmann          No     Gosar             NotVoting 
Bartlett          Aye      Bachus            No     Pascrell          NotVoting 
Bass(CA)          Aye      Barletta          No     Rogers(AL)        NotVoting 
Becerra           Aye      Barrow            No     Sanchez,Loretta   NotVoting 
Berkley           Aye      Barton(TX)        No     Slaughter         NotVoting 
Berman            Aye      Bass(NH)          No     Speier            NotVoting 
Bishop(NY)        Aye      Benishek          No 
Bishop(UT)        Aye      Berg              No 
Blumenauer        Aye      Biggert           No 
Bonamici          Aye      Bilbray           No 
Boswell           Aye      Bilirakis         No 
Brady(PA)         Aye      Bishop(GA)        No 
Braley(IA)        Aye      Black             No 
Broun(GA)         Aye      Blackburn         No 
Brown(FL)         Aye      Bonner            No 
Butterfield       Aye      BonoMack          No 
Capps             Aye      Boren             No 
Capuano           Aye      Boustany          No 
Carnahan          Aye      Brady(TX)         No 
Carney            Aye      Brooks            No 
Carson(IN)        Aye      Buchanan          No 
Castor(FL)        Aye      Bucshon           No 
Chu               Aye      Buerkle           No 
Cicilline         Aye      Burgess           No 
Clarke(MI)        Aye      Burton(IN)        No 
Clarke(NY)        Aye      Calvert           No 
Cleaver           Aye      Camp              No 
Clyburn           Aye      Campbell          No 
Cohen             Aye      Canseco           No 
Connolly(VA)      Aye      Cantor            No 
Conyers           Aye      Capito            No 
Cooper            Aye      Carter            No 
Courtney          Aye      Cassidy           No 
Critz             Aye      Chabot            No 
Crowley           Aye      Chaffetz          No 
Cummings          Aye      Chandler          No 
Davis(CA)         Aye      Coble             No 
Davis(IL)         Aye      Coffman(CO)       No 
DeFazio           Aye      Cole              No 
DeGette           Aye      Conaway           No 
DeLauro           Aye      Costa             No 
Deutch            Aye      Cravaack          No 
Dicks             Aye      Crawford          No 
Dingell           Aye      Crenshaw          No 
Doggett           Aye      Cuellar           No 
Doyle             Aye      Culberson         No 
Duncan(TN)        Aye      Davis(KY)         No 
Edwards           Aye      Denham            No 
Engel             Aye      Dent              No 
Eshoo             Aye      DesJarlais        No 
Farr              Aye      Diaz-Balart       No 
Fattah            Aye      Dold              No 
Frank(MA)         Aye      Donnelly(IN)      No 
Fudge             Aye      Dreier            No 
Garamendi         Aye      Duffy             No 
Gibson            Aye      Duncan(SC)        No 
Gonzalez          Aye      Ellison           No 
Green,Al          Aye      Ellmers           No 
Green,Gene        Aye      Emerson           No 
Griffith(VA)      Aye      Farenthold        No 
Grijalva          Aye      Fincher           No 
Gutierrez         Aye      Fitzpatrick       No 
Hahn              Aye      Flake             No 
Hanabusa          Aye      Fleischmann       No 
Hastings(FL)      Aye      Fleming           No 
Heinrich          Aye      Flores            No 
Higgins           Aye      Forbes            No 
Himes             Aye      Fortenberry       No 
Hinchey           Aye      Foxx              No 
Hinojosa          Aye      Franks(AZ)        No 
Hirono            Aye      Frelinghuysen     No 
Hochul            Aye      Gallegly          No 
Holden            Aye      Gardner           No 
Holt              Aye      Garrett           No 
Honda             Aye      Gerlach           No 
Hoyer             Aye      Gibbs             No 
Huelskamp         Aye      Gingrey(GA)       No 
Israel            Aye      Gohmert           No 
Jackson(IL)       Aye      Goodlatte         No 
JacksonLee(TX)    Aye      Gowdy             No 
Johnson(GA)       Aye      Granger           No 
Johnson(IL)       Aye      Graves(GA)        No 
Johnson,E.B.      Aye      Graves(MO)        No 
Jones             Aye      Griffin(AR)       No 
Kaptur            Aye      Grimm             No 
Keating           Aye      Guinta            No 
Kildee            Aye      Guthrie           No 
Kind              Aye      Hall              No 
Kucinich          Aye      Hanna             No 
Labrador          Aye      Harper            No 
Langevin          Aye      Harris            No 
Larsen(WA)        Aye      Hartzler          No 
Larson(CT)        Aye      Hastings(WA)      No 
Lee(CA)           Aye      Hayworth          No 
Lewis(GA)         Aye      Heck              No 
Loebsack          Aye      Hensarling        No 
Lofgren,Zoe       Aye      Herger            No 
Lowey             Aye      HerreraBeutler    No 
Luján             Aye      Huizenga(MI)      No 
Lynch             Aye      Hultgren          No 
Maloney           Aye      Hunter            No 
Markey            Aye      Hurt              No 
Matsui            Aye      Issa              No 
McClintock        Aye      Jenkins           No 
McCollum          Aye      Johnson(OH)       No 
McDermott         Aye      Johnson,Sam       No 
McGovern          Aye      Jordan            No 
McNerney          Aye      Kelly             No 
Meeks             Aye      King(IA)          No 
Michaud           Aye      King(NY)          No 
Miller(NC)        Aye      Kingston          No 
Miller,George     Aye      Kinzinger(IL)     No 
Moore             Aye      Kissell           No 
Moran             Aye      Kline             No 
Murphy(CT)        Aye      Lamborn           No 
Nadler            Aye      Lance             No 
Napolitano        Aye      Landry            No 
Neal              Aye      Lankford          No 
Olver             Aye      Latham            No 
Pallone           Aye      LaTourette        No 
Pastor(AZ)        Aye      Latta             No 
Paul              Aye      Levin             No 
Pelosi            Aye      Lewis(CA)         No 
Perlmutter        Aye      Lipinski          No 
Peters            Aye      LoBiondo          No 
Petri             Aye      Long              No 
Pingree(ME)       Aye      Lucas             No 
Polis             Aye      Luetkemeyer       No 
Price(NC)         Aye      Lummis            No 
Quigley           Aye      Lungren,DanielE.  No 
Rahall            Aye      Mack              No 
Rangel            Aye      Manzullo          No 
Rehberg           Aye      Marchant          No 
Reyes             Aye      Marino            No 
Ribble            Aye      Matheson          No 
Richardson        Aye      McCarthy(CA)      No 
Richmond          Aye      McCarthy(NY)      No 
Rothman(NJ)       Aye      McCaul            No 
Roybal-Allard     Aye      McCotter          No 
Rush              Aye      McHenry           No 
Ryan(OH)          Aye      McIntyre          No 
Sánchez,LindaT.   Aye      McKeon            No 
Sarbanes          Aye      McKinley          No 
Schakowsky        Aye      McMorris,Rodgers  No 
Schiff            Aye      Meehan            No 
Schrader          Aye      Mica              No 
Schwartz          Aye      Miller(FL)        No 
Scott(VA)         Aye      Miller(MI)        No 
Scott,David       Aye      Miller,Gary       No 
Sensenbrenner     Aye      Mulvaney          No 
Serrano           Aye      Murphy(PA)        No 
Sherman           Aye      Myrick            No 
Shimkus           Aye      Neugebauer        No 
Shuler            Aye      Noem              No 
Sires             Aye      Nugent            No 
Smith(WA)         Aye      Nunes             No 
Stark             Aye      Nunnelee          No 
Sutton            Aye      Olson             No 
Thompson(CA)      Aye      Owens             No 
Thompson(MS)      Aye      Palazzo           No 
Tierney           Aye      Paulsen           No 
Tipton            Aye      Pearce            No 
Tonko             Aye      Pence             No 
Towns             Aye      Peterson          No 
Tsongas           Aye      Pitts             No 
VanHollen         Aye      Platts            No 
Velázquez         Aye      Poe(TX)           No 
Visclosky         Aye      Pompeo            No 
Walz(MN)          Aye      Posey             No 
Wasserman,Schultz Aye      Price(GA)         No 
Waters            Aye      Quayle            No 
Watt              Aye      Reed              No 
Waxman            Aye      Reichert          No 
Welch             Aye      Renacci           No 
Wilson(FL)        Aye      Rigell            No 
Woolsey           Aye      Rivera            No 
Yarmuth           Aye      Roby              No 
                           Roe(TN)           No 
                           Rogers(KY)        No 
                           Rogers(MI)        No 
                           Rohrabacher       No 
                           Rokita            No 
                           Rooney            No 
                           Ros-Lehtinen      No 
                           Roskam            No 
                           Ross(AR)          No 
                           Ross(FL)          No 
                           Royce             No 
                           Runyan            No 
                           Ruppersberger     No 
                           Ryan(WI)          No 
                           Scalise           No 
                           Schilling         No 
                           Schmidt           No 
                           Schock            No 
                           Schweikert        No 
                           Scott(SC)         No 
                           Scott,Austin      No 
                           Sessions          No 
                           Sewell            No 
                           Shuster           No 
                           Simpson           No 
                           Smith(NE)         No 
                           Smith(NJ)         No 
                           Smith(TX)         No 
                           Southerland       No 
                           Stearns           No 
                           Stivers           No 
                           Stutzman          No 
                           Sullivan          No 
                           Terry             No 
                           Thompson(PA)      No 
                           Thornberry        No 
                           Tiberi            No 
                           Turner(NY)        No 
                           Turner(OH)        No 
                           Upton             No 
                           Walberg           No 
                           Walden            No 
                           Walsh(IL)         No 
                           Webster           No 
                           West              No 
                           Westmoreland      No 
                           Whitfield         No 
                           Wilson(SC)        No 
                           Wittman           No 
                           Wolf              No 
                           Womack            No 
                           Woodall           No 
                           Yoder             No 
                           Young(AK)         No 
                           Young(FL)         No 
                           Young(IN)         No 

R 112 2nd U.S. House of Representatives 291 H R 4310 On Passage 
RECORDED VOTE 
Passed 18-May-2012 12:46 PM 
National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2013 
Party       Ayes Noes Answered-“Present” Not Voting
Republican  222  16   0                  3
Democratic  77   104  0                  9
Independent 0    0    0                  0
Totals      299  120  0                  12

For Detention            Against Detention        Not There
Ackerman          Aye    Amash             No     Amodei            NotVoting 
Adams             Aye    Baldwin           No     Braley(IA)        NotVoting 
Aderholt          Aye    Bass(CA)          No     Cardoza           NotVoting 
Akin              Aye    Becerra           No     Costello          NotVoting 
Alexander         Aye    Blumenauer        No     Filner            NotVoting 
Altmire           Aye    Bonamici          No     Gosar             NotVoting 
Andrews           Aye    Burgess           No     Pascrell          NotVoting 
Austria           Aye    Butterfield       No     Ryan(OH)          NotVoting 
Baca              Aye    Campbell          No     Sanchez,Loretta   NotVoting 
Bachmann          Aye    Capps             No     Slaughter         NotVoting 
Bachus            Aye    Capuano           No     Speier            NotVoting 
Barletta          Aye    Carson(IN)        No     Sullivan          NotVoting 
Barrow            Aye    Castor(FL)        No 
Bartlett          Aye    Cicilline         No 
Barton(TX)        Aye    Clarke(MI)        No 
Bass(NH)          Aye    Clarke(NY)        No 
Benishek          Aye    Clay              No 
Berg              Aye    Cleaver           No 
Berkley           Aye    Clyburn           No 
Berman            Aye    Cohen             No 
Biggert           Aye    Conyers           No 
Bilbray           Aye    Crowley           No 
Bilirakis         Aye    Davis(IL)         No 
Bishop(GA)        Aye    DeFazio           No 
Bishop(NY)        Aye    DeGette           No 
Bishop(UT)        Aye    DeLauro           No 
Black             Aye    Deutch            No 
Blackburn         Aye    Doyle             No 
Bonner            Aye    Duncan(TN)        No 
BonoMack          Aye    Edwards           No 
Boren             Aye    Ellison           No 
Boswell           Aye    Eshoo             No 
Boustany          Aye    Farr              No 
Brady(PA)         Aye    Fattah            No 
Brady(TX)         Aye    Frank(MA)         No 
Brooks            Aye    Fudge             No 
Broun(GA)         Aye    Garamendi         No 
Brown(FL)         Aye    Gibson            No 
Buchanan          Aye    Griffith(VA)      No 
Bucshon           Aye    Grijalva          No 
Buerkle           Aye    Gutierrez         No 
Burton(IN)        Aye    Hahn              No 
Calvert           Aye    Hastings(FL)      No 
Camp              Aye    Himes             No 
Canseco           Aye    Hinchey           No 
Cantor            Aye    Holt              No 
Capito            Aye    Honda             No 
Carnahan          Aye    Huelskamp         No 
Carney            Aye    Jackson(IL)       No 
Carter            Aye    Johnson(GA)       No 
Cassidy           Aye    Johnson(IL)       No 
Chabot            Aye    Jones             No 
Chaffetz          Aye    Keating           No 
Chandler          Aye    Kind              No 
Chu               Aye    Kucinich          No 
Coble             Aye    Labrador          No 
Coffman(CO)       Aye    Larsen(WA)        No 
Cole              Aye    Lee(CA)           No 
Conaway           Aye    Lewis(GA)         No 
Connolly(VA)      Aye    Lofgren,Zoe       No 
Cooper            Aye    Lowey             No 
Costa             Aye    Luján             No 
Courtney          Aye    Lynch             No 
Cravaack          Aye    Maloney           No 
Crawford          Aye    Markey            No 
Crenshaw          Aye    Matsui            No 
Critz             Aye    McClintock        No 
Cuellar           Aye    McCollum          No 
Culberson         Aye    McDermott         No 
Cummings          Aye    McGovern          No 
Davis(CA)         Aye    Michaud           No 
Davis(KY)         Aye    Miller(NC)        No 
Denham            Aye    Miller,George     No 
Dent              Aye    Moore             No 
DesJarlais        Aye    Moran             No 
Diaz-Balart       Aye    Murphy(CT)        No 
Dicks             Aye    Nadler            No 
Dingell           Aye    Napolitano        No 
Doggett           Aye    Neal              No 
Dold              Aye    Nugent            No 
Donnelly(IN)      Aye    Olver             No 
Dreier            Aye    Pallone           No 
Duffy             Aye    Paul              No 
Duncan(SC)        Aye    Pelosi            No 
Ellmers           Aye    Peters            No 
Emerson           Aye    Pingree(ME)       No 
Engel             Aye    Polis             No 
Farenthold        Aye    Price(NC)         No 
Fincher           Aye    Quigley           No 
Fitzpatrick       Aye    Rahall            No 
Flake             Aye    Rangel            No 
Fleischmann       Aye    Richmond          No 
Fleming           Aye    Roe(TN)           No 
Flores            Aye    Rothman(NJ)       No 
Forbes            Aye    Roybal-Allard     No 
Fortenberry       Aye    Royce             No 
Foxx              Aye    Rush              No 
Franks(AZ)        Aye    Sánchez,LindaT.   No 
Frelinghuysen     Aye    Sarbanes          No 
Gallegly          Aye    Schakowsky        No 
Gardner           Aye    Schrader          No 
Garrett           Aye    Schwartz          No 
Gerlach           Aye    Schweikert        No 
Gibbs             Aye    Scott(VA)         No 
Gingrey(GA)       Aye    Serrano           No 
Gohmert           Aye    Stark             No 
Gonzalez          Aye    Thompson(CA)      No 
Goodlatte         Aye    Thompson(MS)      No 
Gowdy             Aye    Tierney           No 
Granger           Aye    Tonko             No 
Graves(GA)        Aye    VanHollen         No 
Graves(MO)        Aye    Velázquez         No 
Green,Al          Aye    Wasserman,Schultz No 
Green,Gene        Aye    Waters            No 
Griffin(AR)       Aye    Watt              No 
Grimm             Aye    Waxman            No 
Guinta            Aye    Welch             No 
Guthrie           Aye    Wilson(FL)        No 
Hall              Aye    Woolsey           No 
Hanabusa          Aye    Yarmuth           No 
Hanna             Aye
Harper            Aye
Harris            Aye
Hartzler          Aye
Hastings(WA)      Aye
Hayworth          Aye
Heck              Aye
Heinrich          Aye
Hensarling        Aye
Herger            Aye
HerreraBeutler    Aye
Higgins           Aye
Hinojosa          Aye
Hirono            Aye
Hochul            Aye
Holden            Aye
Hoyer             Aye
Huizenga(MI)      Aye
Hultgren          Aye
Hunter            Aye
Hurt              Aye
Israel            Aye
Issa              Aye
JacksonLee(TX)    Aye
Jenkins           Aye
Johnson(OH)       Aye
Johnson,E.B.      Aye
Johnson,Sam       Aye
Jordan            Aye
Kaptur            Aye
Kelly             Aye
Kildee            Aye
King(IA)          Aye
King(NY)          Aye
Kingston          Aye
Kinzinger(IL)     Aye
Kissell           Aye
Kline             Aye
Lamborn           Aye
Lance             Aye
Landry            Aye
Langevin          Aye
Lankford          Aye
Larson(CT)        Aye
Latham            Aye
LaTourette        Aye
Latta             Aye
Levin             Aye
Lewis(CA)         Aye
Lipinski          Aye
LoBiondo          Aye
Loebsack          Aye
Long              Aye
Lucas             Aye
Luetkemeyer       Aye
Lummis            Aye
Lungren,DanielE.  Aye
Mack              Aye
Manzullo          Aye
Marchant          Aye
Marino            Aye
Matheson          Aye
McCarthy(CA)      Aye
McCarthy(NY)      Aye
McCaul            Aye
McCotter          Aye
McHenry           Aye
McIntyre          Aye
McKeon            Aye
McKinley          Aye
McMorrisRodgers   Aye
McNerney          Aye
Meehan            Aye
Meeks             Aye
Mica              Aye
Miller(FL)        Aye
Miller(MI)        Aye
Miller,Gary       Aye
Mulvaney          Aye
Murphy(PA)        Aye
Myrick            Aye
Neugebauer        Aye
Noem              Aye
Nunes             Aye
Nunnelee          Aye
Olson             Aye
Owens             Aye
Palazzo           Aye
Pastor(AZ)        Aye
Paulsen           Aye
Pearce            Aye
Pence             Aye
Perlmutter        Aye
Peterson          Aye
Petri             Aye
Pitts             Aye
Platts            Aye
Poe(TX)           Aye
Pompeo            Aye
Posey             Aye
Price(GA)         Aye
Quayle            Aye
Reed              Aye
Rehberg           Aye
Reichert          Aye
Renacci           Aye
Reyes             Aye
Ribble            Aye
Richardson        Aye
Rigell            Aye
Rivera            Aye
Roby              Aye
Rogers(AL)        Aye
Rogers(KY)        Aye
Rogers(MI)        Aye
Rohrabacher       Aye
Rokita            Aye
Rooney            Aye
Ros-Lehtinen      Aye
Roskam            Aye
Ross(AR)          Aye
Ross(FL)          Aye
Runyan            Aye
Ruppersberger     Aye
Ryan(WI)          Aye
Scalise           Aye
Schiff            Aye
Schilling         Aye
Schmidt           Aye
Schock            Aye
Scott(SC)         Aye
Scott,Austin      Aye
Scott,David       Aye
Sensenbrenner     Aye
Sessions          Aye
Sewell            Aye
Sherman           Aye
Shimkus           Aye
Shuler            Aye
Shuster           Aye
Simpson           Aye
Sires             Aye
Smith(NE)         Aye
Smith(NJ)         Aye
Smith(TX)         Aye
Smith(WA)         Aye
Southerland       Aye
Stearns           Aye
Stivers           Aye
Stutzman          Aye
Sutton            Aye
Terry             Aye
Thompson(PA)      Aye
Thornberry        Aye
Tiberi            Aye
Tipton            Aye
Towns             Aye
Tsongas           Aye
Turner(NY)        Aye
Turner(OH)        Aye
Upton             Aye
Visclosky         Aye
Walberg           Aye
Walden            Aye
Walsh(IL)         Aye
Walz(MN)          Aye
Webster           Aye
West              Aye
Westmoreland      Aye
Whitfield         Aye
Wilson(SC)        Aye
Wittman           Aye
Wolf              Aye
Womack            Aye
Woodall           Aye
Yoder             Aye
Young(AK)         Aye
Young(FL)         Aye
Young(IN)         Aye

If your representative voted against the amendment and/or for final passage of this year's NDAA,
I need you to contact them immediately and demand they change their misguided views and stop allowing the military to arrest and detain innocent citizens.

Let your representative know you’ve seen through the smokescreen that was the Gohmert amendment, and you aren’t fooled for a second.

In addition, make sure your representative realizes that Section 1021 of the NDAA was declared unconstitutional this week in a U.S. District Court, and that a temporary stay on enforcement of that measure has been granted.

Finally, make it clear you'll be telling your fellow constituents that your representative abandoned them to a growing police state.

Congress created this unconstitutional mess, and it’s Congress that will have to fix it.

After you've contacted your representative,
get in touch with your senators to demand they vote against the NDAA as long as it contains these indefinite detention provisions.

And stay tuned to
CampaignforLiberty.org, as we look ahead to fighting this bill in the Senate next week and doing our best to prevent the government from being able to indefinitely detain innocent Americans.

In Liberty,

Tim Shoemaker
Director of Legislation

P.S. Earlier today, the U.S House
voted down an amendment that would have prohibited the military from being able to indefinitely detain you. It later voted for final passage of this year's NDAA.

If your representative voted against the Smith/Amash amendment or voted for final passage,
contact them immediately to demand they change their misguided view and stop allowing the military to arrest and detain Americans!

Then
contact your senators to urge them to vote against the NDAA as long as it contains these provisions.

As the fight over the FY 2013 NDAA heads to the Senate,
please chip in $10 or $25, or whatever you can afford, so C4L can continue leading the fight to prevent the military from detaining you for as long as it wants.

No comments: